Achieve Your Immigration Goals in The U.S. Trust your case to the honest & caring attorneys at Milla & Associates.

The Provisional Waiver

March 4, 2013 marked the first day that immigrant visa applicants could file provisional waivers for unlawful presence. Under the prior procedure, individuals had to leave the U.S. before applying for the waiver, thus living abroad (and likely apart) from U.S. citizen family. If those previous statements make sense to you, you have probably already done your celebratory dance for this significant step forward in U.S. immigration procedures. If that statement made you turn your face in confusion, you are not alone, but after reading more you may realize that you too have reason to celebrate. Although the process just started in March, and we are waiting to see how the system is fully implemented, there is cause for optimism. Ready for a ride through the whirlwind of waivers? Ready.

The new procedure affects certain individuals who are subject to three- and ten-year bars to admission into the U.S. for having unlawful presence in the U.S. (for example, after entering without a visa). Let me break that down. A person can begin accruing unlawful presence in the U.S. by a variety of ways, but the most common are by entering without a valid visa or by violating the terms of an existing valid visa stay in the U.S. If a person has accrued enough unlawful presence in the U.S. because, for example, he entered without a visa, then as soon as he departs the U.S. he will automatically trigger a penalty (three or ten years) to returning to the U.S. The length of penalty depends on the length of unlawful presence in the U.S. If a person has over 180 days but less than one year of unlawful presence, he is subject to a three-year bar to reentry. If a person has over one year or more of unlawful presence, he triggers a ten-year penalty. Still with me? Good.

Immigration law allows for waivers of those penalties, commonly called “hardship waivers.” The term “hardship waiver” stems from the standard for approving the waivers. To get the waiver of the unlawful presence penalty approved, the applicant must show that he has a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident (a.k.a. “green card holder”) spouse or parent who will suffer “extreme hardship” if the waiver is denied. (Notably, children cannot be the qualifying relative for an unlawful presence waiver.) Essentially, the applicant will need to show that if he is denied admission to the U.S., the citizen or resident spouse or parent will suffer extreme hardship if he or she is 1) forced to live apart from the applicant and 2) forced to live abroad to remain united with the applicant. What is extreme hardship? In short, it is something beyond ordinary. This of course begs the question, what is ordinary about the consequences of forcing spouses to live apart?

Under the previous procedure, a person who could not apply for a green card in the U.S. (for example, through marriage to a U.S. citizen) and was subject to an unlawful presence bar would 1) leave the U.S. for the interview; 2) trigger the penalty upon departure; 3) attend the visa interview abroad; 4) file the waiver at, or after, the interview; 5) wait for a decision on the waiver while abroad; 6) wait some more; and 7) remain outside of the U.S. until a decision was made. Of course, only if the waiver was approved (effectively waiving the penalty) could the individual then receive the visa and return. If the waiver was not granted, the applicant was denied the visa and was then stuck with essentially three options: 1) file a new waiver (more time and money); 2) appeal (more money and T-I-M-E, to state it mildly, considering that up until very recently, appeals were taking around twenty-six months); or the utterly undesirable option to 3) wait abroad for the penalty to run. All the while, spouses were forced to live apart, children were separated from parents, and U.S. citizens were forced to live abroad, severing ties to family, home, and employment and all other opportunities and resources in the U.S.

Although under the new provisional waiver procedures individuals will still have to depart for the interview, the integral change will now allow applicants to file for the waiver before leaving for the interview. Therefore, families will remain together in the U.S. while the waiver is decided. With the new process, the agency implemented a change to alleviate the burdensome and lengthy separation times that the old procedure forced on families. One must be eligible, however, to file for the waiver. USCIS has a helpful site explaining the eligibility requirements and filing process. Note, among the requirements, provisional waivers are only for the three- and ten-year unlawful presence bars; they will not waive other inadmissibility grounds (such as criminal and misrepresentation bars). That is why the waiver is called “provisional.” It only applies to the unlawful presence bars. The waiver’s approval does not preclude a denial should the consulate officer conclude that the applicant is inadmissible on another ground. In addition to reading the USCIS link, I suggest that a potential applicant consult with an experienced immigration attorney (private/nonprofit) to review eligibility for the provisional waiver process, determine the strength of the waiver case, and provide guidance in developing the hardship factors. Since the provisional waiver process is only getting started, it will be important to learn from an experienced practitioner exactly how the process is being implemented.

While the provisional waiver is a far cry from much needed immigration reform, it is certainly a step in the right direction. As an immigration attorney, I have known dozens of clients who have suffered through the forced separation that the consulate process and unlawful presence penalties induce. I have seen U.S. citizens lose homes and jobs because of the financial and emotional strain of separation while waivers were pending. Homes were foreclosed on; bankruptcies were filed; educational opportunities were lost. Citizens had children without their spouses at their side, and citizens were unable to witness births because they had to stay in the U.S., maintain a job, and keep the family (at home and abroad) afloat. Husbands suffered through sleepless nights. Mothers’ tender touches were felt only through Skype. Children’s hands reached out for absent parents in the night.

What I have witnessed is just a fraction of the total impact that the waiver bars and separation have caused, but I have no doubt my cases are an all too accurate sampling of the greater harm that those penalties have generated. That is why the provisional waiver will be a very welcome change. While consular processing with a waiver is a wild and difficult ride, I can acknowledge the good that also results (although, of course, the government certainly makes you earn it). The approval brings a life-altering swing in status from “unlawful” and unwanted to that of lawful permanent resident with rights and privileges in the U.S.

Thank you for joining me on this ride through the provisional waiver. I look forward to more developments and improvements to our immigration system as both sides cross the aisle to meet somewhere in the middle. More changes are needed to fix our broken immigration system, but as an attorney who has witnessed the suffering of far too many families, I admit I did a little dance when I learned that certain people (yes, they are people) could stay together while the waiver was adjudicated. These will be interesting times, to say the least (and the obvious). March 4th marked the beginning for provisional waivers. It got us off on the right foot in 2013, hopefully setting the tone for greater reform to come. Looking forward to having you join me on the ride again soon.

*Originally published by Robert C. Milla at The Immigration Pages on March 4, 2013.

If you have questions about the provisional waiver, please contact Robert C. Milla for a free consultation.

  • Highly recommend!

    “We were referred to Mr. Milla by our previous attorney, who felt that our case had "hit the wall." In our opinion, R. Milla was the best thing that happened to our case! After over three years filled with nothing but frustration, we've asked for Robert's help. Our case was approved and I received my Green Card in just a few months. Robert was always up-front and honest about the possible outcome, answered all our never-ending questions and addressed all concerns. The phone calls and e-mail communications were always answered in a timely and professional manner. Our case was based on marriage to US citizen and had some roadblocks along the way, but thanks to Robert's expertise, we are very happy campers now, planning our first vacation abroad! Result: Application for adjustment of status to permanent resident (“green card”) approved after filing a mandamus action in federal court for an unreasonable delay”

    Anonymous

  • Successful case for marriage-based green card

    “Milla & Associates delivers an incredible quality of legal representation and it was an absolute pleasure to work with Robert Milla, Tatiana Alonso, and their team. My husband and I entrusted them with my adjustment of status and green card application. Our case was handled very efficiently, they answered our questions at every stage and kept us informed of the next steps and developments throughout the process. Not only that, Robert is highly experienced and has an incredible understanding of immigration law on top of being genuine, personable and transparent. It is really hard to be able to find a good attorney that genuinely cares about the case, he is trustworthy, and I can tell that he does his work with his heart. My adjustment of status/green card was approved within a week from the interview, and I received my conditional green card in the mail a few days after receiving the approval notice. Robert and his team definitely made the entire process seamless. I would strongly recommend Robert Milla for anyone who is looking for a great immigration attorney and to be put in the best position possible with obtaining a green card. Thank you, Robert, for making my husband and I feel at ease as we navigated through uncharted waters. We are so grateful for you!”

    E & H

  • We can't say enough good things about Robert!

    “We can't say enough good things about Robert!”

    Georgia K.

  • Knowledgeable and Accessible Immigration Attorney

    “Result: Application for adjustment of status to permanent resident (“green card”) approved Robert Milla has been our attorney for years as my wife and I waited and waited for DOMA to be struck down and he was right there the minute it happened to represent us in attaining her Permanent Resident Status. We couldn’t be happier with Robert's expertise, availability to talk with us and answer all our questions and skillfully represent us throughout the past few years of this important process. I highly recommend him to any family with immigration issues. He is very knowledgeable and accessible to his clients.”

    Anonymous

  • Mr. Robert is an amazing, humble and extremely knowledgeable ...

    “Words just cannot express how grateful I'm to Robert Milla for all his efforts and dedication towards my case. It was a very complicated case and I had consulted a lot of attorneys in Chicago who were just not that confident in proceeding with my case. Then I met Robert and his knowledge and determination showed me light when I was almost about to give up. He was confident and Knowledgeable and did a meticulous job with my case especially when ​I had very less time to apply. I'm so relieved and happy that I got my green card within a week of the interview. Mr Robert is an amazing, humble and extremely knowledgeable attorney. He gives a lot of attention to detail. I'll never forget that he helped me when I was most in need of help. It was easy to work with ​Robert and legal assistant Maria. They made the process very smooth and kept me informed throughout the process.​ ​I couldn't have asked for a more knowledgeable, friendly, and courteous attorney.​ ​I appreciate His genuineness and humbleness. I highly recommend him for all immigration needs and I will definitely use your services again in future.”

    Sameena

  • The Best Lawyer Ever!

    “I had problems bringing my wife back to US. Couple different lawyers promised to help but just wasted my money and time. Robert Milla told me upfront what we need to do and finally my wife is back. The Best Lawyer Ever! Result: Hardship waiver application approved (misrepresentation) and immigrant visa granted for permanent resident status (“green card”)”

    Pavel

  • Successful N-400 While Working Abroad

    “One cannot go wrong with Robert! He is a great listener, who understood my unique immigration situation very quickly and guided me throughout the process. He helped me apply for N-400 with some tricky background. Robert prepared me for the interview and gave me the confidence I needed for the interview, which resulted in a smooth approval of my N-400. I highly recommend him for all your immigration needs. I am now seeking his advice for my other family members.”

    Bhoopesh

  • Highly recommend

    “I highly recommend Robert Milla. I was recommended to Mr. Milla by a friend of mine who used him for her permanent residency application as well. Both my husband were touched by the fact that Robert took the time to get to know us during our first meeting with him, before we began the application process. Throughout the process, Robert was very helpful answering any questions we had and educating us on our legal rights. I was a nervous wreck on the day of my permanent residency interview, and Robert put all my fears at ease by assuring me that I had absolutely nothing to worry about. Rest assured, Robert will be my choice as I go to apply for my citizenship in the next few years! Result: Application for adjustment of status to permanent resident (“green card”) approved”

    Surabhi

  • Very satisfied and grateful!

    “After a long and difficult journey for my niece to obtain American Citizenship, from delay to denial, a big sigh of relief finally came for my whole family when her case/application got approved. Robert is intelligent . He is skilled, very knowledgeable of immigration laws, helpful and truly honest attorney . We are very satisfied and grateful to Milla and Associates law firm . I would definitely recommend Robert Milla and his firm .”

    Victor

  • Highly recommended!

    “My wife and I used Robert Milla as our attorney to file for my wife's green card (through marriage). He was careful, friendly, knowledgeable and attentive (much better than a previous immigration attorney we hired for a different matter). Everything went smoothly with our application and interview, and my wife now has her green card! Highly recommended!”

    Ben